Why beauty brands offer a GWP at the holidays, and how to read a rival's gift offer

What do GWP and PWP mean, and why do beauty brands run them at the holidays?
GWP means gift with purchase: a free item added to an order, usually above a spend threshold. PWP means purchase with purchase: an extra item sold at a reduced price, only alongside another purchase. Beauty brands run both at the holidays because the gift adds value while the product keeps its full price, and it puts another product in the shopper's hands. Between October 1 and November 19, 2026, RivalSweeper recorded a gift with purchase on 11 of the 31 beauty store homepages where it recorded offer messages.
This post is for the person who plans the offer, or who has to answer a rival's. It covers why the gift exists, how the threshold, the limited quantity and the coupon rules work, whether shoppers think it is a good deal, and how to read a competitor's gift offer from the outside. For the short definition and a worked example, see the glossary entry on what GWP means in sales.
GWP vs PWP: free, or cheaper with a purchase
The cleanest definition is in a company filing. The Estée Lauder Companies say they provide "gift with purchase promotional products to certain customers generally without additional charge" and "purchase with purchase promotional products to certain customers at a discount in relation to prices charged for saleable product". (Form 10-K, fiscal year ended June 30, 2026)
So a GWP is free once the order qualifies, and a PWP is something the shopper pays for, at a price they can only get with another purchase. On November 19, 2026, Estée Lauder's own site listed a "12-Piece Holiday Blockbuster with 9 Full-Size Favorites $90 with any purchase." (esteelauder.com promotions page) The page doesn't call it a PWP, but that is the mechanic.
The choice between the two is not only about margin. In a 2013 study, shoppers' "willingness to pay for the product after the promotion is retracted is higher when it was offered for free than when it was offered at a low, discounted price." (Palmeira and Srivastava, Journal of Consumer Research, 2013) A low PWP price can become the number shoppers remember. A free gift has no price to remember.
4 reasons beauty brands offer a GWP at the holidays

1. The price stays where it is
Marigay McKee, a former president of Saks Fifth Avenue, put it this way: "The luxe brands will give you mini samples as a value-add without the need to reduce the ticket price, which is more of a mass strategy," (BeautyMatter, December 2022)
Karen Young, who spent decades at Estée Lauder and Lancôme, said of sales: "We all felt it brought down the brand image. Yes, we did GWPs, PWPs, and holiday sets, but those seemed in keeping with the brand." (BeautyMatter, January 2025) In the weeks when every store shows a percentage, a gift is a way to make an offer without printing a lower price.
2. It is sampling, paid for by an order
The Estée Lauder Companies list "purchase with purchase and gift with purchase" among their sampling programs, and explain why sampling matters: "Sampling is a key promotional activity as it allows consumers to experience product quality and perceived benefits directly". (Form 10-K, fiscal 2026) The gift goes to someone who has just bought.
3. The threshold lifts the basket
A Mary Kay consultant described the effect to the Baltimore Sun in 2004: "You set a certain dollar amount and as people get close to it, you just say, 'Well, you know, you can get one of these if you just spend five more dollars.' It's amazing. It really works." (Baltimore Sun, republished in The Vindicator, May 2004) Retailers now say it to shoppers directly. Ulta's guide to its gifts advises: "If you're just shy of a spending requirement, look for something you'll genuinely use to close the gap." (Ulta Beauty)
4. A gift is less likely to shrink next to a big basket
A 2003 paper argued that the value of a free premium "may be less likely than a comparable discount to be viewed in a relative sense". (Nunes and Park, Journal of Marketing Research, 2003) Ten dollars off a large order looks small. A pouch of minis is less likely to be judged that way.
None of this makes the gift a sure thing. Lindsay Knaak-Stuart, founder of the beauty brand Meant, said in 2019: "Last year we offered a gift with purchase (GWP) only, but found what customers really want (and expect) on Black Friday/Cyber Monday is a discount." (Beauty Independent, November 2019) That matches part of what RivalSweeper saw on beauty homepages this year: 5 of the 11 stores with a gift offer showed it next to a percentage discount, not in place of one.
What RivalSweeper saw on 31 beauty store homepages
RivalSweeper reads the homepage banners and marketing messages of the stores it tracks every day. Between October 1 and November 19, 2026, RivalSweeper recorded offer messages (a first reading or a change) on 31 beauty store homepages from 27 brands, and 11 of the 31 showed a gift with purchase at least once. Here is what those 11 stores' gift offers looked like.
| What the homepage showed | Beauty stores (of the 11 with a gift offer in RivalSweeper's data) |
|---|---|
| A spend threshold for the gift | 10 of 11 |
| The gift at the same time as a percentage discount | 5 of 11 |
| A code needed for at least one gift | 5 of 11 |
| "No code needed" or "added automatically" | 3 of 11 |
| "While supplies last" or "while stock lasts", in any language | 2 of 11 |
| Two or more thresholds at once, with a different gift at each | 3 of 11 |
| A change of gift or threshold inside the seven weeks | at least 5 of 11 |
On the 7 stores in RivalSweeper's data that stated the threshold in US dollars, it ran from $42 to $400, and $75 appeared on 4 of them. In the same seven weeks, RivalSweeper received emails from 12 beauty stores, and 5 of the 12 put a free-gift offer in a subject line.
Read these as a small sample. The 31 stores are beauty stores RivalSweeper tracks, not the whole market, and the 11 with a gift offer come from 10 brands. RivalSweeper's homepage record starts in November for about half of the 31 stores, so not every store was read for the whole seven weeks, and the window ends eight days before Black Friday (November 27, 2026). The counts come from what the homepage said: RivalSweeper did not place orders or test a checkout.
How the spend threshold works
The threshold is the part of the offer that does the selling, so the details in the terms matter. Clinique's offer terms, read on November 19, 2026, said: "To be eligible for the offer, the purchase minimum must be met before tax and shipping/handling fees and after any other promotions and discounts are applied." (clinique.com offers page) Under a rule like that, a discount code can push an order back below the gift line.
Shoppers know the game. On r/Sephora, one explained why a cheap add-on sells so well: "Those stupid $3 nose strips are so popular...I think precisely because people buy them to hit a threshold lol" (r/Sephora, August 2023)
Thresholds also move. In RivalSweeper's data, one beauty store swapped a gift at $200 for a different gift at $75 in mid-November, and another showed gifts at four thresholds in under three weeks ($125, $150, $250 and $400), under three codes. I could not find a source outside software vendors for a rule on where to set the threshold, so I won't give one. Your own order values are the better guide.
Why holiday GWP offers have limited quantities
The gift is a promotional item with its own stock, and the terms let the brand stop when it is gone. Estée Lauder's promotions page, read on November 19, 2026, said: "Quantities are limited and all offers are subject to availability while supplies last." It also said: "We reserve the right to substitute any free item offered with an item of equal or greater value." (esteelauder.com promotions page) Clinique's page gave an end time and added "or while supplies last". (clinique.com offers page)
A promotion built on special stock has to be forecast. Cody Plofker, CMO of Jones Road, made the comparison when talking about a limited kit of minis (a paid kit, not a gift): "[If] we were doing a discount and we had too much, [that would be] fine, because we can just sell that inventory the next month," (Glossy, December 2023)
Running out has a cost. When an Ulta gift sold out early one morning in October 2026, the most upvoted reply in the Reddit thread was: "That makes it easier for me to decide lol, not buying anything today since it sold out and I missed it." (r/Ulta, October 2026) The gift was the reason for the order, so when the gift went, the order went with it.
Can shoppers stack a coupon code with a GWP?
It depends on the store, and the stores disagree. Clinique's terms, read on November 19, 2026: "One offer per person and one offer code per order." (clinique.com offers page) Estée Lauder's 15% loyalty sign-up discount, the same day: "Not valid with any other discounts, special offers, including gift with purchase and purchase with purchase programs." (esteelauder.com promotions page)
Ulta takes the opposite line in its guide: "One of the best parts of shopping at Ulta Beauty is that many offers stack." (Ulta Beauty) Its Black Friday event is the exception: products in it "cannot be combined with or purchased using any scannable coupon, coupon code, or other code-based offer." (Ulta Black Friday page, read November 19, 2026)
For the person designing the offer, the choice is code or no code. Where a checkout takes one code, a gift that needs a code makes the shopper pick between the gift and the discount. A gift that is added automatically leaves the code box free. On the beauty homepages in RivalSweeper's data, 5 of the 11 stores asked for a code for at least one gift and 3 said the gift needed none. In the same RivalSweeper data, 5 of the 11 stores did the stacking themselves by showing the gift together with a percentage discount.
Is a GWP a good deal? What shoppers say
Shoppers split it into two cases. If the order was going to happen anyway, the gift is welcome: "I don't think I'd ever spend money just for a GWP but they're nice additions if you're already spending that much regardless" (r/Ulta, June 2024) If the gift is the reason to spend more, they warn each other off: "It's worth being strategic and timing your purchases to get a GWP but it's really not worth spending more to get them." (r/Ulta, March 2026)
The "worth" figure is the brand's own. Estée Lauder's page footnotes its set value as "*Based on suggested retail price." (esteelauder.com promotions page, read November 19, 2026) One homepage in RivalSweeper's data advertised a gift as a $125 value on a $42 order. And the shopper does not pick what is in it. As the author Paula Begoun said of gifts with purchase: "It's not necessarily your lipstick color, not necessarily a product your skin needs." (Baltimore Sun, republished in The Vindicator, May 2004)
Is the gift better than buying full size? One shopper's answer: "If I'm thinking of ordering something just for a GWP then I'm realizing I should just buy the products in the GWP that are tempting me." (r/Ulta, March 2026)
There is a lesson here for the brand. One study tested the hypothesis that a product offered as a free gift "will be valued less as evinced by lower purchase intentions and a lower price that consumers are willing to pay", and its abstract lists the "presence of alternate price information to make judgments about the value of the gift" among the conditions that inhibit the effect. (Raghubir, Journal of Consumer Psychology, 2004) The research is not settled (the 2013 study above found a free offer "does not devalue the product at all"), but saying what the gift sells for is cheap insurance.
When holiday GWP offers start and end
There is no single season. On the beauty homepages RivalSweeper tracks, gift offers were already on record when the window opened on October 1, 2026, and at least 5 of the 11 stores changed the gift or its threshold before November 19.
Single offers can be short. On November 19, 2026, both of Clinique's gift offers carried the same line: "Offer ends 11/21/2026 at 3:00 a.m. EST or while supplies last." (clinique.com offers page) Others outlast the sale they arrive with. Ulta's Black Friday event "Ends Saturday, November 28th", while its fragrance gift on the same page reads "Valid 11.22.26 - 1.01.27." (Ulta Black Friday page, read November 19, 2026)
So a competitor's gift has two end dates: the printed one, and the day the stock runs out. Only the first is on the banner.
5 signs a rival's GWP is working (or isn't)
You can't see a competitor's orders, so every sign below is an indication, not proof. Even the merchant running the offer can struggle to tell. One wrote on r/ecommerce: "But really I've no idea if it's 'worth it', as I've no way of measuring that." (r/ecommerce, August 2022)
- The gift is gone before its end date. A banner that disappears early, a "sold out" note or a substituted gift suggests demand beat the forecast.
- The same offer comes back. Brands repeat what paid. A gift that returns on the same week next year, or again next month, was probably worth running.
- A discount appears on top. If a gift-only offer gains a percentage a few days in, the gift alone was probably not enough. Steph Chen, founder of the cookware brand Anyday, described the pressure: "the more other companies discount the more it necessitates us to do it." (Modern Retail, November 2023)
- The threshold moves. A lower threshold with the same gift reads as a push for volume. A higher one reads as confidence. Check whether the gift changed too before you conclude anything.
- The offer spreads to more channels. A gift that starts in the promo bar and then shows up in email subject lines and ads has budget behind it.
On your own offer the questions are easier, because you have the orders: how many orders cleared the threshold, what the average order was against a normal week, and whether people who got the gift came back for the full size.
How to watch rivals' GWP offers
A price tracker will not show a gift, because no price changes. The offer lives in the promo bar, the emails, the ads, the cart and the terms page.
- Check the places gifts are announced. Homepage banner and promo bar, newsletters, ads and the offers or terms page of each rival.
- Write down five things. The gift, the threshold, code or automatic, the end date and any "while supplies last" line, and what the gift is combined with.
- Date the first and last day you saw it. The dates are what turn single sightings into a promotional calendar you can plan against next year.
- Separate gifts from gift words. On the beauty homepages RivalSweeper read, "gift" also meant gift guides, gift sets, gift cards and gift finders. None of those is a gift with purchase.
- Read it next to their discounts. A rival that moves from a percentage to a gift, or adds one to the other, is changing how it competes. Compare with its discount depth and its free shipping threshold.
Doing this by hand for five rivals means five homepages, five inboxes and five terms pages, every day in the busiest weeks of the year. The by-hand version is described in the competitor-watch routine, step by step.
What RivalSweeper does instead: RivalSweeper checks each competitor's site every day and records its promotions and coupon codes, its homepage banners and marketing messages, the newsletters it sends and its Meta and Google ads activity, each with a date. A gift offer shows up in RivalSweeper as a changed homepage message or a new promotion even when no price moves. RivalSweeper reads public pages only, so it shows what a rival offered and when, not how many shoppers took it. The full list is on the product facts page, and beauty teams can start with competitor monitoring for beauty brands.
The short version
- A GWP is free with a qualifying order. A PWP is a reduced price you can only get with another purchase.
- Beauty brands use the gift at the holidays to add value without printing a lower price, to sample, and to lift the basket to a threshold.
- In RivalSweeper's data, 11 of the 31 beauty store homepages with offer messages on record between October 1 and November 19, 2026 showed a gift with purchase, and 5 of those 11 showed it together with a percentage discount.
- Stacking depends on the terms: a gift that needs a code competes with the discount code, and an automatic gift does not.
- To read a rival's gift, record the gift, the threshold, the code, the dates and what it is combined with, then watch what changes.
Frequently asked questions
Why do beauty brands offer a GWP at the holidays?
A gift with purchase adds value while the product keeps its full price, puts a sample of another product in the shopper's hands, and gives shoppers a reason to spend up to a threshold. In the trade press, former Saks Fifth Avenue president Marigay McKee described minis as a value-add "without the need to reduce the ticket price". At the holidays the gift often comes with a discount: 5 of the 11 beauty stores where RivalSweeper recorded a gift with purchase between October 1 and November 19, 2026 showed it at the same time as a percentage discount.
What is the difference between GWP and PWP?
With a gift with purchase (GWP) the extra item is free once the order qualifies. With a purchase with purchase (PWP) the shopper pays a reduced price for the extra item, and can only buy it alongside another purchase. The Estée Lauder Companies' annual report describes gift with purchase products as given "generally without additional charge" and purchase with purchase products as sold "at a discount".
Can you stack a coupon code with a gift-with-purchase offer?
It depends on the store's terms, so read them before you count on it. Clinique's offer terms, read on November 19, 2026, said "one offer code per order", so a gift that needs a code can't be combined with a discount code there, while Ulta's own guide says "many offers stack". Of the 11 beauty stores where RivalSweeper recorded a gift with purchase on the homepage, 5 asked for a code for at least one gift and 3 said the gift needed no code or was added automatically.
Why do holiday GWP offers have limited quantities?
Because the gift is a promotional item with its own limited stock, and the terms let the brand end the offer when it runs out. Estée Lauder's promotions page, read on November 19, 2026, said "Quantities are limited and all offers are subject to availability while supplies last." RivalSweeper saw "while supplies last" or "while stock lasts" wording, in English or another language, on 2 of the 11 beauty store homepages that showed a gift with purchase.
Are gift-with-purchase offers a good deal, or is buying full size better?
Often yes if you were going to place the order anyway, and rarely if you spend more only to reach the threshold. The stated value is the brand's own figure (Estée Lauder's page footnotes it as "Based on suggested retail price"), and the gift is usually minis you did not choose. If one product in the gift is the one you want, buying it full size can be the better use of the money. With skincare, check that the minis suit your skin before the gift decides the order.
When do holiday GWP offers usually start and end?
There is no fixed season. On the beauty store homepages RivalSweeper tracks, gift-with-purchase offers were already showing in early October 2026 and kept changing through mid-November: at least 5 of the 11 stores that showed one changed the gift or its threshold. Single offers are often short and some run long: on November 19, 2026, Clinique's two gift offers were set to end on November 21, while an Ulta fragrance gift was listed as valid from November 22, 2026 to January 1, 2027. Most also end early if the gift runs out.
What is the difference between a holiday GWP and a gift set?
A gift set is a product: several items sold together at one price. A holiday GWP is free and only comes with a qualifying order. A purchase with purchase sits between the two: a set sold at a reduced price, but only alongside another purchase.
Free research report
Get the October 2026 Online Retail Radar
Anonymized September numbers from the stores we track: how many ran ads and how long the ads lasted, AI-agent readiness scores, payment methods and shipping carriers, and how new stores launched. We email you the link to the full report.
Prefer to skim first? Read the summary.
